Small Crack, Big Boat Job - An Insurance Dilemma

Rob and Rachel Hamill dismantle the crossbeam on Javelot in a Trinidad boatyard after an insurance surveyor flags cracked bushing welds, sparking a tough debate on marine insurance costs.

Rob and Rachel Hamill stand in the noisy boatyard in Trinidad, facing an unexpected refit project aboard their catamaran, Javelot. After completing a fiberglass hull rebuild and taking a brief pause to watch nesting leatherback turtles at Grande Riviere, The Cruising Kiwis planned to splash the vessel back into the Caribbean Sea. Instead, an unresolved survey finding brought maintenance back to the forefront.

Six months earlier, an insurance surveyor inspected the vessel and flagged a crack in the weld holding the bushings in place for the forward crossbeam, deeming the fitting unfit for purpose. The crack predated the family’s purchase of the boat in 2014, and previous surveys and engineering evaluations had concluded a repair was unnecessary. This time, the surveyor highlighted the sheer forces acting on the connection, giving the crew a firm ultimatum: “No repair, no insurance.”

Rigging and Cutting a Frozen Crossbeam Bolt

To access the cracked weld, the yard crew needed to drop the entire crossbeam. The procedure required loosening the side stays to allow the mast to rake forward, cutting away old wire rigging, and disconnecting the forestay. With the rig secured, attention shifted to extracting the heavy retaining bolts from the beam’s mounting tongue.

The operation immediately ran into a mechanical standstill when the primary bolt refused to move. Boatyard worker Chris severed the bolt head and attempted to hammer the shaft backward to gain better leverage, but the hardware remained locked solid. As Rob observed, “The bolt is completely frozen in the tongue of this crossbeam there.” Rather than abandoning the effort, Rob rented a reciprocating saw to cut directly through both sides of the bolt on either side of the tongue, working methodically through the metal so the seized shaft could later be pressed out in a machine shop.

Evaluating the Math of Marine Insurance

Cutting through heavy marine fasteners prompted Rob to reflect on the mounting cost of keeping a cruising vessel insured. The crew pays close to $6,000 USD annually for hull and liability coverage. While they felt immense gratitude for an insurance payout of $43,000 USD following a severe lightning strike in Australia in 2019, modern policy conditions presented a different financial equation.

Their current policy carries a $10,000 USD excess deductible. When factoring in the excess, rising renewal rates, and the administrative strain of claims, the crew elected to fund recent hull repairs out of pocket rather than submit a claim that barely exceeded the threshold. Over the past 7 years, the family has paid over $42,000 USD in premiums without filing a single claim. Diverting those funds into a dedicated maintenance reserve would have funded an entire repair reserve, raising practical questions about the balance between commercial coverage and self-insurance.

Boatyard Amenities and Workshop Logistics

While mechanical work continued at the bow, Rachel loaded up laundry for a trek across the expansive yard. Carrying large sacks across the hardstand, she explained her routine: “I like to save my laundry up until I have lots of it, making it a more worthwhile trip.”

The boatyard perimeter in Trinidad houses concentrated marine workshops covering propellers, rigging, and canvas fabrication under one roof. Because the island sits south of the main hurricane belt, cruisers utilize the facility for seasonal storage. Boats hauled across the yard are wrapped in custom plastic awnings heat-shrunk with blowers, with air conditioners circulating chilled air inside closed cabins to deter tropical mold. Rachel concluded her walk past the travel lift and Patches restaurant, dropping off her wash before picking up a book from the local cruisers’ exchange.

Crossbeam Removal and Workshop Repairs

Back on the hardstand, Rob completed the final saw cuts through the hardware. As the second bolt freed up, the crew lowered the trampoline and lowered the aluminum spar safely to the deck. Upon inspection, a critical mounting component dropped loose to the ground. Rob noted the failure: “This was and should have been attached to the crossmember, but it was not attached at all.”

The detached plate was supposed to mate directly to the tongue with a washer. With the spar detached, the crew arranged for a welder to transport the beam to the fabrication shop, where technicians must rebuild the weld in 4 places before reinstalling the structural assembly.

Refit and Insurance Financial Breakdown

MetricDetails
Annual Insurance PremiumClose to $6,000 USD per year
2019 Australia Lightning Claim$43,000 USD insurance payout
Policy Deductible (Excess)$10,000 USD per occurrence
7-Year Premium Outlay (Zero Claims)Over $42,000 USD
Crossbeam Bushing Rebuild Points4 weld locations required

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the crew remove the crossbeam in Trinidad?

Their insurance surveyor flagged a cracked bushing weld, stating coverage would not renew without completing the repair.

How was the frozen crossbeam bolt removed?

After hammering failed, Rob used a reciprocating saw to make cuts through the bolt on either side of the tongue.

How much does the crew pay annually for vessel insurance?

The Cruising Kiwis pay close to $6,000 USD per year to insure their catamaran Javelot.

What insurance claim did the crew receive in 2019?

They received $43,000 USD after a severe lightning strike in Australia damaged electrical and navigation systems.

Why did the crew decline an insurance claim for recent hull damage?

Their policy has a $10,000 USD excess, so the crew paid out of pocket to avoid premium hikes and administrative friction.

What repair work is required on the removed crossbeam?

A welder must rebuild the bushing weld in 4 places at the marine workshop before the beam can be reinstalled.

Book a trip where this was filmed — near Grenada

See all 14 experiences in Grenada →

Support The Cruising Kiwis

At WeBoating.com, we profoundly acknowledge the unwavering dedication that The Cruising Kiwis invests in crafting each and every video or voyage. Their passion for delivering exceptional ocean content shines through every frame, and it's a labor of love that deserves your attention.

We invite you to watch their captivating videos here and actively engage with their content, including their social media links above. Liking, commenting, and sharing their work goes a long way in fueling their creative fire.

We're also inviting you to explore the gear, sponsorships, and boat partnerships highlighted in the "Small Crack, Big Boat Job - An Insurance Dilemma" video description, or directly on YouTube. By engaging with these offerings or purchasing services and items, you directly support The Cruising Kiwis, their collaborators, and the brands they're associated with.

To ensure you never miss an offshore update, consider visiting their official YouTube Channel to subscribe, like, and join their community directly.

If you have any feedback, corrections, or additional information about The Cruising Kiwis or their videos, please use the comment form below to share your thoughts with us.

Thank you for being a part of our community and supporting the creators we cherish. Your time and support truly matter!

Small Crack, Big Boat Job - An Insurance Dilemma

Welcome back to Trinidad, our catamaran and a new round of boat work. This week we're throwing ourselves into a big job to solve a small problem.
During our insurance survey, cracks in the weld that hold the bushings in place for the cross bar were deemed unfit for purpose. Although these cracks predate the ownership of our floating home, this time the message was clear no repair no insurance. It's an insurance dilemma. To repair the weld we need to remove the forestay and disconnect the crossbeam. A big job to correct a small problem. When you look at the numbers it leaves us questioning, is the peace of mind this brings worth the price?

Music
Musicbed.com

Thank you very much for supporting our channel. If you'd like to help with the production of these videos, repairs and maintenance you can do so here:

TIPJAR https://tipjar.thecruisingkiwis.com
SHOP Www.thecruisingkiwis.shop
PATREON Www.patreon.com/cruisingkiwis
PayPal using our email [email protected]

WEB SITE
www.thecruisingkiwis.com

SOCIAL MEDIA
Follow us on: Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/THECRUISINGKIWIS
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/THECRUISINGKIWIS


Much love to you all,
Rob, Rachel, Finn, Declan, Ivan
https://www.patreon.com/CruisingKiwis


*****
Follow us in real time on Instagram and Facebook
@thecruisingkiwis
@finn_hamill
@declan_hamill
@ivanhamill

#sailing #boat #sailinglife #TheCruisingKiwis

Small Crack, Big Boat Job - An Insurance Dilemma Location

  • Chaguaramas Boatyard, Trinidad (10.6845,-61.6385)
  • Grande Riviere, Trinidad (10.828,-61.052)
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply


Latest Episodes from The Cruising Kiwis

Explore the most recent voyages. Subscribe to the channel to never miss an update!

Showing 1-6 of 633 results
Beyond the Boatyard – Exploring Hidden Trinidad
The Cruising Kiwis

Beyond the Boatyard – Exploring Hidden Trinidad

After splashing Javelot in Trinidad, Rob, Rachel, and Declan Hamill venture beyond the boatyard to hike Covigne Gorge, witness leatherback turtle hatchlings at Grande Riviere, and join a beach cleanup on Chacachacare Island.
From Crash Damaged to Splash Day – How we did it!
The Cruising Kiwis

From Crash Damaged to Splash Day – How we did it!

At Peake's Boatyard in Trinidad, Rob and Rachel Hamill wrap up two months of hard labor repairing hull rock damage, straightening rudders, replacing wind generator bearings, and splashing their catamaran back into Chaguaramas Bay.
Boat Problems & Family Celebrations, The Boys Start New Life without us!
The Cruising Kiwis

Boat Problems & Family Celebrations, The Boys Start New Life without us!

Rob and Rachel Hamill tackle cracked crossbeam welds on Javelot in Trinidad, celebrate superyacht jobs for Declan and Ivan, and mark their 25th wedding anniversary.
Small Crack, Big Boat Job – An Insurance Dilemma
The Cruising Kiwis

Small Crack, Big Boat Job – An Insurance Dilemma

Rob and Rachel Hamill dismantle the crossbeam on Javelot in a Trinidad boatyard after an insurance surveyor flags cracked bushing welds, sparking a tough debate on marine insurance costs.
It’s Over – Escape to the Ocean
The Cruising Kiwis

It’s Over – Escape to the Ocean

Rob and Rachel Hamill manage an intensive haul-out aboard catamaran Javelot in Chaguaramas, Trinidad, while their sons Declan and Ivan complete an Atlantic cargo voyage.
Fiberglass Repair | There’s a Hole in Our Boat
The Cruising Kiwis

Fiberglass Repair | There’s a Hole in Our Boat

The Cruising Kiwis undertake a structural fiberglass hull repair on Javelot, executing a 12:1 scarf bevel and core restoration to ensure ocean readiness.
Browse All Videos
WeBoating
Logo
Shopping cart