Peter Lukursky—known as Plukky on SAILING into FREEDOM—takes a skeptical look at Sailing La Vagabonde, the SeaPeople mobile application, and the promotional campaign billed as Free the Wind. After opening with a brief comedic lip-sync joke, Plukky contrasts the early appeal of Sailing La Vagabonde—a simple ocean romance of a boy meeting a girl on a boat and sailing the seven seas with Elena—against their latest commercial pitch claiming to have liberated marine weather forecasting for sailors worldwide.
To evaluate whether the campaign delivers anything that mariners did not already possess, Plukky audits the specific marketing statements made by Riley and the SeaPeople team before putting the app’s advertised Route Intelligence Planning through a practical 35-mile upwind routing test in the northern part of the UK.
Plukky plays promotional clips in which Sailing La Vagabonde announces, “We have just gone and done something so insane. It is our gift to you guys. What was a billion-dollar-a-year industry is now free for everyone,” promising access on the SeaPeople app “for free for 100 years, no catches, no gimmicks.” In those clips, Riley argues that meteorological information is collected by government agencies around the world using taxpayer dollars, only to be packaged up and sold back to consumers—a system he says people do not find fair.
Plukky immediately challenges that framing, pointing out that government meteorological agencies around the globe have always made their weather data freely available to the public, and that the vast majority of marine weather applications built on top of that public data are likewise free to download and use.
“You’re making it sound like this government data has been viciously guarded by the overlords, only to be divvied out when you pay them some money. What complete and utter rubbish. The weather data has always been free around the world.”
— Plukky, SAILING into FREEDOM
Questioning how someone can gift sailors something they already have, Plukky notes, “I’ve been using free weather for like years and years and years.” When presenters repeatedly insist there are no gimmicks, he reads out the literal definition of a gimmick: a clever trick, device, or unusual feature designed temporarily to grab attention, boost publicity, or convince people to buy a product or support an idea. He then points directly to the campaign’s own promotional tactics featured in the clips—handing out piles of free shirts and organizing a Saturday at 5:00 p.m. march on the main street where supporters hold signs and chant—joking about whether Greta was invited to the rally.
While acknowledging that a limited number of specialized forecasting platforms charge money to upgrade from their free tiers to premium versions, Plukky explains why those upgrades exist. PredictWind, for example, applies dedicated algorithm code and detailed processing to raw weather models to make offshore passage planning safer. Alongside established tools such as Windy and Yachtara, sailors have long had access to both free baseline forecasts and optional advanced routing tools.
More tellingly, Plukky highlights a contradiction in Riley’s own recent sailing footage. Despite urging the public to download SeaPeople because “you can go and get the most up-to-date premium weather for free,” Riley was filmed in one of his latest videos checking forecasts on windy.com—which offers both a free version and a paid premium tier—and in another recent video using PredictWind rather than beta testing SeaPeople’s Free the Wind feature himself. As Plukky summarizes the contradiction: “Do as I say, not as I do.”
To see why a crew might still rely on PredictWind or Windy instead of SeaPeople, Plukky examines the feature promoted as Route Intelligence Planning—noting the subtle verbal sleight of hand between calling a tool route intelligence planning versus route intelligent planning. In promotional clips, the SeaPeople team states, “Our team at Sea People, they tinkered away and they managed to build the best weather interface. We just want to make the ocean safer for everyone.”
Plukky opens the SeaPeople app in the northern part of the UK and plots a 35-mile course directly upwind. Immediately, a fundamental limitation appears: the planner has no mechanism to import or account for boat polar performance diagrams, which define a sailing vessel’s actual speed across every point of sail.
“Now, Sea People’s Free the Wind app has no ability to take in your boat polar performance diagrams, which basically is your boat’s performance at every point of sail. The app merely asks you for the boat speed you intend to do, which is a joke.”
— Plukky, SAILING into FREEDOM
Entering an intended boat speed of 7 knots and selecting an early Saturday morning departure window, Plukky lets the app calculate the passage. Instead of computing tacking angles around the eye of the wind, the router draws a dead-straight line directly into the headwind and reports a total passage time of 4 hours and 59 minutes.
“And it takes you only 4 hours and 59 minutes for the journey. No zigzag course sailing upwind at all. What a joke. So, basically, it doesn’t take the wind into consideration at all.”
— Plukky, SAILING into FREEDOM
Beyond ignoring wind direction on an upwind leg, Plukky identifies additional routing hazards during his hands-on trial of the interface:
Plukky remarks sarcastically that if a sailor accidentally plots a course straight through an island on the free version of SeaPeople’s Free the Wind app, they can rely on SeaPeople’s magic to get over the land—or pay to upgrade from the free version to reach their destination safely.
| Test Parameter / Campaign Claim | Recorded Value in Episode | Observed Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Northern UK Upwind Test Distance | 35 miles | Plotted directly into the oncoming wind |
| Target Boat Speed Input | 7 knots | Manual speed entry required; no boat polar diagrams supported |
| Calculated Upwind Transit Time | 4 hours 59 minutes | Dead-straight line into the wind with no zigzag tacking course |
| Advertised Free Weather Duration | 100 years | Promoted as a no-catches, no-gimmicks gift on SeaPeople |
| Promotional Street March Time | Saturday at 5:00 p.m. | Main street sign-holding rally paired with free shirt giveaways |
Wrapping up his evaluation, Plukky argues that making the ocean safer for everyone would require offering capabilities beyond what sailors already have for free. Instead, he concludes, “It’s another free weather app, just like all the other free weather apps out there.” In his view, the narrative that weather data was jealously guarded by vicious billion-dollar overlords until Sailing La Vagabonde knocked them for a six is simply a marketing story crafted to drive app downloads and finance the creators’ next lifestyle choice—prompting him to tell his fellow Australian creators, “Shame on you for lying to your audience and to everyone, basically. And you’re Australian, so double shame on you.”
When Plukky sets a 35-mile course directly upwind in the northern part of the UK and enters a target boat speed of 7 knots for an early Saturday morning departure, the SeaPeople app plots a dead-straight line straight into the wind taking 4 hours and 59 minutes with no zigzag tacking course.
No. According to Plukky’s test, the app has no ability to import boat polar performance diagrams and instead only asks the user to type in an intended boat speed in knots.
In addition to routing straight into headwinds without tacking, the planner fails to account for cross-currents and loses small island detail when zoomed out on the map, allowing routes to be plotted straight through islands.
Sailing La Vagabonde claimed to make a billion-dollar weather industry free for 100 years with no gimmicks, whereas Plukky points out that government weather data and most weather apps using it have always been free, and notes that Riley was filmed using Windy.com and PredictWind in recent videos rather than SeaPeople.
At WeBoating.com, we profoundly acknowledge the unwavering dedication that SAILING into FREEDOM invests in crafting each and every video or voyage. Their passion for delivering exceptional ocean content shines through every frame, and it's a labor of love that deserves your attention.
We invite you to watch their captivating videos here and actively engage with their content, including their social media links above. Liking, commenting, and sharing their work goes a long way in fueling their creative fire.
We're also inviting you to explore the gear, sponsorships, and boat partnerships highlighted in the "Sailing LA Vagabonde is Lying - Free wind my Ar@#'se" video description, or directly on YouTube. By engaging with these offerings or purchasing services and items, you directly support SAILING into FREEDOM, their collaborators, and the brands they're associated with.
To ensure you never miss an offshore update, consider visiting their official YouTube Channel to subscribe, like, and join their community directly.
If you have any feedback, corrections, or additional information about SAILING into FREEDOM or their videos, please use the comment form below to share your thoughts with us.
Thank you for being a part of our community and supporting the creators we cherish. Your time and support truly matter!
Is “Free the Wind” really giving sailors something that wasn’t already free — and how intelligent is SeaPeople’s route planning when you actually test it? ⛵🌬️
In this episode of Sailing into Freedom, Plukky takes a critical look at "Sailing La Vagabonde, SeaPeople, and the Free the Wind campaign". We compare the claims around “free” weather data with the weather information sailors have long been able to access, then put SeaPeople’s "Route Intelligence Planning" through some simple real-world tests.
What happens when you ask it to route directly upwind? Does it account for boat polars, currents, islands, and actual sailing performance? And how does that compare with established weather and routing tools such as Windy, PredictWind, and Yachtara?
If you’re interested in sailing weather, marine weather routing, passage planning, sailing apps, boat polars, SeaPeople, Sailing La Vagabonde, PredictWind, Windy, or Yachtara, this episode takes a skeptical and practical look at what these tools actually do.
#sailing #sailingintofreedom #seapeople #freethewind #sailinglavagabonde #weatherrouting #predictwind #windy #yachtara #passageplanning
Give it a thumbs up if you liked this episode!
Get your Sailing Into Freedom Crew T-shirt:
https://teespring.com/stores/sailing-into-freedom
Want more? Became our patron and get access to exclusive content. https://www.patreon.com/sailingintofreedom
If you would like to support with single donations click here - https://www.paypal.me/Plukky
Also follow us on -
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sailingintofreedom
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/sailingintofreedom
Our website: https://www.sailingintofreedom.comGive it a thumbs up if you liked this episode!
Explore the most recent voyages. Subscribe to the channel to never miss an update!