RIB vs Inflatable Catamaran Dinghy

Practical Sailor compares traditional hard-bottom RIBs with modern inflatable catamaran dinghies like Takacat and True Kit, evaluating weight, price, stability, and cruising tender performance.
For as long as can be remembered, the cruising dinghy has been more or less a settled science. A 10-ft hard bottom rib, fiberglass or aluminum hull, inflatable tubes wrapped around it. The pointy bit is at the front, a 15 horse Yamaha hanging off the back, and the whole contraption dangling from the davits behind the mothership. That’s been industry standard because frankly, it works. And as noted, “rib is basically a little powerboat.” Underneath those inflatable tubes is an actual hull using fiberglass or aluminum with a V-shape that cuts through the water rather than simply sitting on top of it. And that matters because anchorages aren’t those turquoise Instagram swimming pools you see in the cruising brochure. Sometimes you have 2-ft chop. Sometimes you have 4-ft chop. Sometimes you have a 20-minute ride back to the boat with two adults and four bags of groceries, a case of Coke Zero, and laundry, and snorkeling gear, and something you bought at the hardware store that absolutely does not fit in a dinghy. A decent rib with enough horsepower just handles it. It planes up. It carries the weight. The rigid hull cuts through the chop. You can run several miles down the coast in it. You can land it on a beach. You can bang it into the dinghy dock. And if you have a 10-footer with a 15 horse outboard, there’s enough grunt available that adding another person or another bag of groceries doesn’t automatically turn your planing dinghy into a displacement barge. Take something like an AB 9 and 1/2 ft. It weighs about 110 lb before you add an optional bow locker, would carry about five people rated for 15 horsepower. That’s a substantial little boat and substantial is both its advantage and the problem because once you add an outboard and a fuel tank and an anchor and all the other junk that ends up migrating into your dinghy, you built yourself a small moon orbiting off the back of the sailboat. RIBs are heavy. If you’re hanging one from davits, depending on your boat and the davits and your outboard, you might need to remove that outboard first and that means lifting a very awkward engine while standing in a dinghy while it bounces around trying to hoist it onto the back of a sailboat. It’s one of those activities that becomes considerably less charming with every birthday. The RIBs also collect water. They collect leaves. They collect sand and wherever you park one, the local bird population apparently gets an email. Eventually, the inflatable tubes age out as well. How quickly depends on how heavy the material is, tropical UV exposure and how well you protect them. A good CSM or Hypalon type tube can last a very long time, but the inflatable portion of the boat is still the part that will eventually require attention while the aluminum or fiberglass hull underneath could happily continue existing. Still, we’ve tolerated all of that because these things work.

The Rise of Inflatable Catamaran Dinghies

Which brings us to these, the new kid on the block, the inflatable catamaran dinghy. There are several companies building them now, but two names you’re likely going to run into frequently are Takacat and TrueKit, both with roots in New Zealand. Instead of one conventional inflatable hull wrapped around a V bottom, you basically have two long inflatable pontoons running parallel to one another connected by a high pressure inflatable floor. And immediately, something interesting happens. You remove the heavy, rigid hull. A Takacat T300 LX is basically 10 ft long and weighs only 66 lb. Takacat recommends only 2 and 1/2 to 6 horsepower on that model. A similarly sized True Kit Navigator 300 weighs about 68 lb, carries 1,100 lb in weight, and can take a 10 horse. So, compared to your traditional RIB, we’ve just cut a very substantial amount of weight out of the boat. Now you have my attention. And because the boat’s riding on two relatively narrow hulls with a tunnel between them, there’s less hull dragging through the water. That seems to be the secret sauce with these things. True Kit specifically argues that the lower drag catamaran platform allows owners to use smaller engines than they would need on a conventional deep-V tender. Independent tests have also found these boats capable of getting on plane with surprisingly modest horsepower. And then we get to something I hadn’t really considered until I started researching this. The price. Because a good RIB is not cheap anymore. The current AB, we’re talking about 9 and 1/2 ft aluminum bottom RIB, sells for roughly 6,500 US before you put an outboard on it. A current Highfield Classic 290, another 9 and 1/2 ft aluminum RIB, is being advertised at 6473 for the boat only. That same Highfield dealer lists a short-shaft Yamaha 15 at another 3,500 bucks. So, you’re basically at 10 grand for the classic 10-ft RIB and 15 horsepower setup before you start adding covers and fuel tanks and assorted boat nonsense. Now look at the cats. A Takacat T300 LX currently lists 2 grand. A brand new 6-horse Tohatsu can be found for about 1,600 bucks. So, we’re roughly at 3,700 for the boat and the motor using current advertised prices. Compared with something approaching 10 grand for that premium rib setup. Takacat is also selling boat and outboard packages starting at around 3,100 depending on the model and motor combination. Now, that’s not completely apples to apples. You’re paying more for that rigid aluminum hull, premium tube materials, and very different sort of construction on the rib. But, that’s still a gigantic difference. And, it’s not just because the inflatable cat itself is cheaper. If they both perform satisfactorily with 6 horsepower instead of 15, you’re also buying a smaller outboard, carrying lighter outboard onto the boat every time, burning less fuel, spending less money replacing the outboard someday when it wears out. Suddenly, the economics of this thing start to become fairly compelling.

Stability, Boarding, and Construction Details

Then, there’s stability. Because the buoyancy is spread way out on two pontoons, cat designs are extremely wide and resistant to rolling. That’s potentially excellent when you’re climbing aboard from the mothership, loading groceries, carrying scuba equipment, or trying to get the dog into the boat without conducting an impromptu swimming lesson. Takacat takes the concept even further by leaving the bow and much of the stern wide open. And, at first glance, that looks completely insane. There’s no bow. Someone’s forgotten to finish the boat. But, the idea is actually pretty clever. Swimmers can come aboard through the front instead of climbing over a giant tube, and water can drain out through the open stern instead of sitting inside the boat forever. So, if it rains, it’s okay. Takacat calls it stern system a quick drain tube transom. TrueKit takes a slightly more conventional approach with its Navigator. It has a substantial bow tube because it’s specifically designed as a yacht tender, while some of its other cat designs taper to the pontoons at the front to make boarding from the water easier. But, this is where I start putting my old man glasses back on because there’s still no hard hull underneath you. If I’m dragging my dinghy onto a rocky beach or dealing with shallow coral, oyster shells, submerged junk, or generally abusing the bottom of the boat, which I tend tend to do, I’d much rather have an aluminum or fiberglass hull between the objects I’m hitting and my groceries than some high-pressure inflatable floor. And although the reports I found about the performance are surprisingly positive, I’m not yet prepared to believe that two inflatable tubes are automatically going to replace a proper V hull when the anchorage gets genuinely nasty. There’s another peculiar issue, too. Because these boats have a tunnel between the hull, the water arriving at the propeller isn’t necessarily behaving the same way it does behind a traditional RIB. Takacat itself recommends an anti-ventilation plate for engines above 6 horse and says propeller cupping may be necessary if you experience ventilation. And that’s interesting because one of the great advantages of the traditional RIB is that there isn’t much experimentation involved. We’ve been doing these things forever. Hang the right short-shaft outboard on the transom, put fuel in it, pull the cord, and go get your groceries at 18 knots. The cat may take a little more fiddling. Construction is another thing I’d investigate carefully before buying one of these. True Kit, for example, uses German-made Valmex fabric with thermal-welded seams and gives its boats a 5-year limited warranty. As noted, “truck. It’s heavy, it costs a lot, it” applies when comparing traditional utility.

Cruising Integration and Conclusions

So, where does that leave us? If I lived on a 45-ft cruising boat with serious davits and regularly carried several people to and from different anchorages and got groceries and frequently crossed rough anchorages, I’d still understand exactly why there’s a RIB hanging off the back. It’s a pickup truck. It’s heavy, it costs a lot, it occupies a ridiculous amount of space, birds view it as a toilet, but it does a really good job. On the other hand, if I’m cruising on a smaller sailboat, particularly one without those substantial davits. Suddenly, a 10-ft tender that weighs 60-something pounds that can be packed into bags becomes extremely attractive. And if the same tender can perform properly with 6 horsepower instead of 15, now I have a lighter dinghy, a lighter engine, less fuel, thousands of dollars still in my bank account, and a package I might actually be able to lift onto the foredeck by myself. That’s not a small advantage. So, I started researching this video fairly convinced that someone had simply taken an inflatable dinghy, chopped the bow off, and successfully marketed the missing pieces as innovation. I’m not so convinced anymore. I’m also not ready to trade my RIB in for one of these things because there’s one question the internet can’t properly answer for me. What happens when you take both of them out in genuinely miserable three- or four-foot chop trying to get through the anchorage to the dinghy dock with groceries on board, and you open the throttle, and then you point it back at the sailboat? I think we’re going to have to find out at some point. If you’ve made the switch to a cat-style dinghy, I really want to hear from you in the comments. What’s your experience been like? Does it actually ride better, stay drier, plane easier, and make life aboard simpler? And if you refuse to own one of these things and you’re sticking to your guns with the RIB until someone pries it from your davits, I’d love to hear why as well. And speaking of boat ownership, have you signed up on the Practical Sailor website yet? Practical Sailor’s been around since 1974, which means we’ve built up thousands of articles, tests, and reviews, and how-to resources designed to make owning your boat a little easier, a little safer, and hopefully a little cheaper. While you’re here, don’t forget to give this video a thumbs up and hit subscribe so I can see you again next time. For more independent boat reviews and gear tests, visit Practical Sailor.
How much does a Takacat T300 LX weigh?

A Takacat T300 LX is basically 10 ft long and weighs only 66 lb.

What horsepower does Takacat recommend for the T300 LX?

Takacat recommends only 2 and 1/2 to 6 horsepower on that model.

What fabric do True Kit catamarans use?

True Kit uses German-made Valmex fabric with thermal-welded seams and gives its boats a 5-year limited warranty.

Book a trip where this was filmed — near New Providence Island

See all 130 experiences in New Providence Island →

Support Practical Sailor

At WeBoating.com, we profoundly acknowledge the unwavering dedication that Practical Sailor invests in crafting each and every video or voyage. Their passion for delivering exceptional ocean content shines through every frame, and it's a labor of love that deserves your attention.

We invite you to watch their captivating videos here and actively engage with their content, including their social media links above. Liking, commenting, and sharing their work goes a long way in fueling their creative fire.

We're also inviting you to explore the gear, sponsorships, and boat partnerships highlighted in the "RIB vs Inflatable Catamaran Dinghy" video description, or directly on YouTube. By engaging with these offerings or purchasing services and items, you directly support Practical Sailor, their collaborators, and the brands they're associated with.

To ensure you never miss an offshore update, consider visiting their official YouTube Channel to subscribe, like, and join their community directly.

If you have any feedback, corrections, or additional information about Practical Sailor or their videos, please use the comment form below to share your thoughts with us.

Thank you for being a part of our community and supporting the creators we cherish. Your time and support truly matter!

Trying to figure out which dinghy to buy for your cruising sailboat, the best dinghy for the Bahamas, or which dinghy to use in the Caribbean? In this Practical Sailor video, we compare the traditional hard-bottom RIB with the new generation of inflatable catamaran dinghies, including boats like the Takacat and True Kit. We look at RIB vs Takacat, RIB vs catamaran dinghy, weight, price, stability, planing performance, rough-water handling, horsepower requirements, beaching, storage, davits, durability and how each style works as a real cruising sailboat tender.

For decades, the standard cruising setup has been something like a 10-foot RIB with a 15-horsepower outboard, but lightweight cat dinghies are challenging that formula. Are inflatable catamaran tenders actually better? Should you choose a RIB, cat dinghy, inflatable tender or hard-bottom dinghy for liveaboard cruising? Whether you're outfitting a sailboat for the Bahamas, Caribbean, coastal cruising or long-term cruising, this comparison will help you decide what dinghy is best for your sailboat and which tender setup makes the most sense for the way you cruise.

#PracticalSailor #SailboatDinghy #RIB #Takacat #CatamaranDinghy #InflatableDinghy #YachtTender #CruisingSailboat #Sailing #Liveaboard #BahamasSailing #CaribbeanSailing


Practical Sailor is your trusted resource for reviews of sailboats and sailing gear.
https://www.practical-sailor.com

Chat with us on Facebook! https://www.facebook.com/PracticalSailor/

RIB vs Inflatable Catamaran Dinghy Location

  • (25.0343,-77.3963)
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply


Latest Episodes from Practical Sailor

Explore the most recent voyages. Subscribe to the channel to never miss an update!

Showing 1-6 of 478 results
Twin Wheels on Sailboats: Better Control or Just More Cost? #shorts
Practical Sailor

Twin Wheels on Sailboats: Better Control or Just More Cost? #shorts

Practical Sailor examines whether twin wheels on modern cruising sailboats offer genuine helm control or unnecessary cockpit clutter, weaker leverage, and added cost.
RIB Dinghies: Why Cruisers Still Choose Them #shorts
Practical Sailor

RIB Dinghies: Why Cruisers Still Choose Them #shorts

Cruising sailors choose rigid inflatable tenders for deep-V chop handling and planing power, balancing performance against davit load limits and UV maintenance.
Tartan 3700: Why Do These Sailboats Hold Their Value? #shorts
Practical Sailor

Tartan 3700: Why Do These Sailboats Hold Their Value? #shorts

A 20-year-old Tartan can cost as much as a newer production boat. The Tartan 3700 helps explain why these sailboats occupy their own world of pricing. #TartanSailboats #Tartan3700 #Sailing #UsedBoats
What Happened to the Hallberg Rassy 400
Practical Sailor

What Happened to the Hallberg Rassy 400

Practical Sailor tours the Hallberg-Rassy 400 at the Annapolis Sailboat Show, analyzing its twin spade rudders, wide aft beam, Selden rig, and Swedish build quality for ocean voyaging.
Boat Insurance Explained: Is Age Really the Problem? #shorts
Practical Sailor

Boat Insurance Explained: Is Age Really the Problem? #shorts

Marine insurance underwriters evaluate boat age and maintenance over the sailor's age, debunking rumors that senior mariners face systematic policy denials.
How Old Is Too Old for Standing Rigging?
Practical Sailor

How Old Is Too Old for Standing Rigging?

Standing rigging failure can drop a sailboat's mast in seconds. Practical Sailor breaks down wire fatigue, swage corrosion, insurance requirements, and how to evaluate aging standing rigging.
Browse All Videos
WeBoating
Logo
Shopping cart