One of the Greatest Sea Stories Ever Told...

In the annals of global seafaring, few episodes match the sheer audacity, raw seamanship, and moral resolve witnessed off the frozen shores of Cape Cod in February 1952. Relayed through the narrative lens of Sailing Zingaro and mariner James Evenson, this account revisits what is widely recognized by maritime historians as the greatest small-boat rescue in U.S. Coast Guard history: the perilous mission of the 36-foot motorized lifeboat CG 36500 to save the stranded crew of the fractured T2 tanker SS Pendleton.

While legendary polar narratives like Ernest Shackleton’s Antarctic survival aboard the James Caird dominate public memory, the winter storm of 1952 generated an equally extraordinary crucible of courage. Amidst a blinding nor’easter howling with 70-knot hurricane-force winds and churning 60-foot breaking seas over the treacherous Chatham Bar, four young Coast Guardsmen set out into total darkness on an open wooden vessel designed to hold only twelve people, ultimately returning with thirty-two survivors.

The 1952 Nor’Easter: Catastrophic Hull Fractures of the SS Pendleton and Fort Mercer

On February 18, 1952, a ferocious winter gale struck the New England coastline with freezing temperatures, horizontal blinding snow, and immense oceanic swells. In the waters south of Cape Cod, two separate 503-foot World War II T2 tankers—the SS Pendleton and the SS Fort Mercer—succumbed to catastrophic structural failure. Constructed with brittle, welded steel plates prone to cold-temperature fracturing, both vessels snapped cleanly in half, leaving their bow and stern sections drifting helplessly miles apart in violent seas.

Most Coast Guard cutters and air rescue units were dispatched north to assist the Fort Mercer, whose radio operator managed to transmit distress coordinates before the vessel broke. The SS Pendleton, however, suffered an immediate electrical severance when its hull ruptured, leaving thirty-three men trapped on the drifting stern section with no functioning radio, no navigational control, and only the relentless roar of breaking waves against the dying bulkhead.

Crossing the Chatham Bar: Bernie Webber and the Crew of CG 36500

At the Chatham Coast Guard Station on Cape Cod, Boatswain’s Mate First Class Bernie Webber was ordered to assemble a volunteer crew and take CG 36500—a 36-foot wooden motorized lifeboat powered by a single 90-horsepower Sterling gasoline engine—out across the dreaded Chatham Bar. Webber selected three volunteers: Andrew Fitzgerald, Ervin Maske, and Richard Livesey. To the veteran local fishermen watching from shore, crossing the shallow, shifting sandbar in 60-foot breaking surf was widely considered a suicide mission.

As Webber navigated into the outer breakers, a colossal wave struck the lifeboat, smashing the windshield into shards and tearing the ship’s magnetic compass completely from its mount. Stripped of basic navigation tools and blinded by sleet and freezing sea spray, Webber pressed forward into the open Atlantic, relying purely on engine sound, wave cadence, and innate seamanship to find the derelict tanker stern in pitch darkness.

The Seamanship of the Rescue: Transferring 32 Men in 60-Foot Seas

Emerging through the blizzard, Webber sighted the towering, rust-streaked silhouette of the Pendleton’s stern section, rolling violently as trapped air kept it temporarily afloat. Survivors crowded along the icy deck edge, lowering a flimsy rope Jacob’s ladder down the sheer steel hull. Webber performed an astonishing display of throttle and helm control, timing each colossal swell to bring the small wooden lifeboat alongside the plunging steel plating just long enough for one man to jump.

One by one, thirty-two men leaped from the doomed tanker into the arms of Webber’s crew, landing safely into the bottom of the lifeboat. Only one crew member, the ship’s cook George Myers, was lost when he was pinned between the hull and a massive sea. With thirty-six men packed like sardines into a 36-foot boat whose gunwales were awash, Webber navigated back across the raging bar without a compass, following the sound of the surf to safely dock at Chatham Pier.

SS Pendleton Rescue Summary & Vessel Specifications

Frequently Asked Questions