Ep 155 LifePo4 Lithium Marine Battery Install | One Year Debrief

EXPENSIVE MISCALCULATION
As longtime viewers will know, the point of this channel has never been to shine a favorable light on ourselves. Instead, we’re brutally honest when it comes to admitting our fails. And despite all efforts to be the “no drama” channel, things rarely go perfectly for very long.

So with that in mind, I miscalculated one major aspect of our new battery install last year, and that was in choosing the amperage limit for our Daly BMS units. For sailors (or even RV users), I would say that the issue comes down to how you determine both your battery capacity (in Amp Hours) and how you calculate your BMS size (max Amp draw).

In many if not most cases, these choices will be bounded, literally, by space constraints. My wizened take on the process is to start by making sure your battery capacity is adequate to the need, and once this is determined, simply choose a BMS size that maximizes use of that available capacity. The above might sound obvious, and perhaps it was, but I did it wrong, basing BMS size on expected max draw instead of capacity. It is important to note that Discharge Capacity, or the ability to deliver what most people would imagine as Cold Cranking Amps, is lower for LifePo4 type battery chemistries. For example, a 100Ah hour battery with a 1C discharge limit of 100A will be woefully short if your bow thruster draws north of 600A, as ours turns out to consume. And for sailors, you must add windlass amps to the bow thruster number. This is because you might be needing both pieces of equipment at the same time for Med mooring with anchor. Figure 1500W nominal at 24V=62.5A for our Lofrans Leopard windlass.

When calculating draw vs amp hours, note that amps and amp hours are not the same. Therefore, to provide a simple conversion the battery engineers will tell you that max draw should be 1C or some such, with 1C being 1x capacity for whatever cells you have. Other brands or models of cell could spec different numbers, and even EVE (brand) states that you can draw up to 2C if done rarely. These max discharge limits will be controlled by the BMS, which is programmed internally to intervene as discharge limits are reached. And of course, with each increase in amp draw that is chosen, the BMS units will be physically larger and more expensive.

For me, the error was rooted (as stated in the video) with an incorrect spec shown in our purchasing documents concerning the bow thruster, which is a Vetus monster of a thruster. These thrusters have been manufactured for decades and are still substantially the same today as they were when the boat was manufactured. Yet there are a maddening number of variables involved, including tunnel size, prop size and number of blades, voltage, amp draw, etc. And due to our thruster motor location, squeezed between black and greywater tanks, visual inspection of the manufacturer’s production plate is impossible. No problem. Oyster knew which model they installed, so we went with that.

Except, not. I discovered this when we first started using the bow thruster. With more than a second or two of activation, the entire house bank electrical system would crash. Alarms would sound, the chartplotter and bow thruster controls would reset, rendering them useless. Luckily, engine operation was unaffected. Recovery was quick for the bow thruster, but over a minute for the plotter.

These crashes were the result of the BMS units, all three of them, shutting down at once when they hit their max amp limit. This did the job they were intended for, protecting the batteries, but a shutdown of this sort under intense load is not good for other devices sharing the system due to the large voltage spikes that accompany the event.

Voltage spikes can be devastating, although I suspect them to be more dangerous to 12V systems as the amperage there is doubled in comparison to a 24V system. In any event, it turned out that our older voltage “droppers”, the devices that convert voltage from 24V to 12V, were the most vulnerable. Newer Victron models seemed unaffected. We may have also lost an older GPS antenna, and of course the 24V alternator rectifier and diode pack shown in the episode. And know that fuses and breakers protect against amps, not voltage increases (within reason).

All told, we’re looking at about $1,100 for the upgraded BMS units, upgraded wiring, lugs, etc at $270+/-, $75 for alternator rectifier and diode packs, Raymarine RS150 GPS at $250, 2x Victron Orion 24/12-15 droppers at $45 each, and five full days of labor to complete the install.

We sincerely hope that these lessons might be useful to others.

sailing yacht talisman, sailing, sailing youtube, boating, top sailing, oyster yachts, oyster sailboats, oyster 485, offshore, bluewater, blue water, sailing vlog, sailing vblog, sailing channels, sailing videos, cruising, monohull, EVE batteries, LifePo4, LFP, installing marine lithium batteries, Daly BMS, alternator failure, voltage spike

EXPENSIVE MISCALCULATION
As longtime viewers will know, the point of this channel has never been to shine a favorable light on ourselves. Instead, we're brutally honest when it comes to admitting our fails. And despite all efforts to be the “no drama” channel, things rarely go perfectly for very long.

So with that in mind, I miscalculated one major aspect of our new battery install last year, and that was in choosing the amperage limit for our Daly BMS units. For sailors (or even RV users), I would say that the issue comes down to how you determine both your battery capacity (in Amp Hours) and how you calculate your BMS size (max Amp draw).

In many if not most cases, these choices will be bounded, literally, by space constraints. My wizened take on the process is to start by making sure your battery capacity is adequate to the need, and once this is determined, simply choose a BMS size that maximizes use of that available capacity. The above might sound obvious, and perhaps it was, but I did it wrong, basing BMS size on expected max draw instead of capacity. It is important to note that Discharge Capacity, or the ability to deliver what most people would imagine as Cold Cranking Amps, is lower for LifePo4 type battery chemistries. For example, a 100Ah hour battery with a 1C discharge limit of 100A will be woefully short if your bow thruster draws north of 600A, as ours turns out to consume. And for sailors, you must add windlass amps to the bow thruster number. This is because you might be needing both pieces of equipment at the same time for Med mooring with anchor. Figure 1500W nominal at 24V=62.5A for our Lofrans Leopard windlass.

When calculating draw vs amp hours, note that amps and amp hours are not the same. Therefore, to provide a simple conversion the battery engineers will tell you that max draw should be 1C or some such, with 1C being 1x capacity for whatever cells you have. Other brands or models of cell could spec different numbers, and even EVE (brand) states that you can draw up to 2C if done rarely. These max discharge limits will be controlled by the BMS, which is programmed internally to intervene as discharge limits are reached. And of course, with each increase in amp draw that is chosen, the BMS units will be physically larger and more expensive.

For me, the error was rooted (as stated in the video) with an incorrect spec shown in our purchasing documents concerning the bow thruster, which is a Vetus monster of a thruster. These thrusters have been manufactured for decades and are still substantially the same today as they were when the boat was manufactured. Yet there are a maddening number of variables involved, including tunnel size, prop size and number of blades, voltage, amp draw, etc. And due to our thruster motor location, squeezed between black and greywater tanks, visual inspection of the manufacturer’s production plate is impossible. No problem. Oyster knew which model they installed, so we went with that.

Except, not. I discovered this when we first started using the bow thruster. With more than a second or two of activation, the entire house bank electrical system would crash. Alarms would sound, the chartplotter and bow thruster controls would reset, rendering them useless. Luckily, engine operation was unaffected. Recovery was quick for the bow thruster, but over a minute for the plotter.

These crashes were the result of the BMS units, all three of them, shutting down at once when they hit their max amp limit. This did the job they were intended for, protecting the batteries, but a shutdown of this sort under intense load is not good for other devices sharing the system due to the large voltage spikes that accompany the event.

Voltage spikes can be devastating, although I suspect them to be more dangerous to 12V systems as the amperage there is doubled in comparison to a 24V system. In any event, it turned out that our older voltage “droppers”, the devices that convert voltage from 24V to 12V, were the most vulnerable. Newer Victron models seemed unaffected. We may have also lost an older GPS antenna, and of course the 24V alternator rectifier and diode pack shown in the episode. And know that fuses and breakers protect against amps, not voltage increases (within reason).

All told, we’re looking at about $1,100 for the upgraded BMS units, upgraded wiring, lugs, etc at $270+/-, $75 for alternator rectifier and diode packs, Raymarine RS150 GPS at $250, 2x Victron Orion 24/12-15 droppers at $45 each, and five full days of labor to complete the install.

We sincerely hope that these lessons might be useful to others.









sailing yacht talisman, sailing, sailing youtube, boating, top sailing, oyster yachts, oyster sailboats, oyster 485, offshore, bluewater, blue water, sailing vlog, sailing vblog, sailing channels, sailing videos, cruising, monohull, EVE batteries, LifePo4, LFP, installing marine lithium batteries, Daly BMS, alternator failure, voltage spike

Ep 155 LifePo4 Lithium Marine Battery Install | One Year Debrief Locations

  • Antigua and Barbuda (17.060816,-61.796428)

Note of Recognition for Sailing Talisman

At WeBoating.com, we profoundly acknowledge the unwavering dedication that Sailing Talisman and other creators invests in crafting each and every video. Their passion for delivering exceptional content shines through every frame, and it's a labor of love that deserves your attention.

We invite you to watch their captivating videos and actively engage with their content, including their social media links above. Liking, commenting, and sharing their work goes a long way in fueling their creative fire.

We're also inviting you to explore any sponsorships and partnerships highlighted in the video description of "Ep 155 LifePo4 Lithium Marine Battery Install | One Year Debrief", or directly on YouTube. By considering their offerings or purchasing services and items, you not only support Sailing Talisman but also the brands and collaborators they're associated with.

If you have any feedback, corrections, or additional information about Sailing Talisman or their videos, please use the comment form below to share your thoughts with us.

Thank you for being a part of our community and supporting the creators we cherish. Your time and support truly matter!

Sailing Talisman Lastest Videos

Showing 1-6 of 178 results
Ep 176 Kevin & Wendy | Stellar Sailing from Guadeloupe to Antigua
Sailing Talisman
Ep 176 Kevin & Wendy | Stellar Sailing from Guadeloupe to Antigua
We complete our loop; Antigua, Sint Maarten, British Virgin Islands, USVI, St Croix, and Guadeloupe. This trip is always bittersweet, given that it marks our return home to Antigua. We love Antigua, and it’s our home base, but it means the adventure sa...
Ep 175 The Last of the Unspoiled Caribbean Islands
Sailing Talisman
Ep 175 The Last of the Unspoiled Caribbean Islands
We complete the final portion of our 200nm offshore passage from St Croix to Iles des Saintes, Guadeloupe, and find things exactly as we left them last year. Paradise on earth, honestly. Iles des Saintes is a collection of small islands south of the main ...
Ep 174 Three Days of Caribbean Squalls | Passage to Guadeloupe | Kevin & Wendy
Sailing Talisman
Ep 173 Kevin & Wendy | Rough Sail to St Croix
Sailing Talisman
Ep 173 Kevin & Wendy | Rough Sail to St Croix
Kevin & Wendy Rough Sail to St Croix In this episode we make the hop from St Thomas, USVI to St Croix, a passage of about 34nm due south. As has happened previously, the wind speeds turn to sustained 30 knots. We end up with at least two failures, whi...
Ep 172 More Sailing Adventures in the BVI | Kevin & Wendy
Sailing Talisman
Ep 172 More Sailing Adventures in the BVI | Kevin & Wendy
More Sailing Adventures in the BVIs: Please forgive us if the dates are a bit disjointed. We were using 3x Apple iPhone 14 Pro phones and 5x GoPro action cameras (luckily no drone footage added to the mix), and this meant that this episode is the cleanup ...
Ep 171 The BVIs Never Disappoint | Cooper, Norman, Jost Van Dyke | Kevin & Wendy
Sailing Talisman
Ep 171 The BVIs Never Disappoint | Cooper, Norman, Jost Van Dyke | Kevin & Wendy
The BVIs Never Disappoint Cooper, Norman, Jost Van Dyke In this episode we’re still kicking around the British Virgin Island chain. Not much to say other than what's in the title; Cooper Island, Norman Island, Jost Van Dyke. Tons of fun as always. ...

Something AWESOME is coming!
Be the FIRST to know⛵

Sign up for exclusive updates and be the first to hear when we go live!
Get sneak peeks, exciting announcement, and special content straight to your inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

WeBoating
Logo
Shopping cart